Excessive fee litigation began with billion dollar plans. It has not stayed there. Plan committees at mid sized organizations now face the same theories with a fraction of the governance infrastructure.

For years, fiduciary liability felt like a large plan problem. The headline excessive fee cases named household name sponsors with enormous 401(k) plans, and mid sized organizations reasonably concluded the plaintiffs bar had bigger targets. That conclusion is now out of date. The litigation model has been standardized, the cost of filing has dropped, and complaints against plans well under a billion dollars in assets have become routine.

The legal theory is stable: plan fiduciaries breached their duty of prudence by permitting excessive recordkeeping fees, retaining underperforming investment options, or failing to run competitive vendor processes. What varies is the defendant's ability to demonstrate a prudent process. Cases are won and lost on committee minutes, benchmarking records, and documented vendor reviews.

The insurance dimension

Fiduciary liability coverage is inexpensive relative to the exposure it addresses, which is precisely why it tends to be under examined. Many organizations carry limits set years ago, sized to a smaller plan and an older litigation environment. Settlement patterns have moved; limits often have not. Retentions for class action claims deserve particular attention, as some forms apply separate and much higher retentions to exactly the claims most likely to arrive.

The committee that cannot produce three years of minutes is not judged on the quality of its decisions. It is judged on the absence of the record.

What sponsors should do

Three actions cover most of the ground. Benchmark fiduciary limits against current settlements for plans of comparable size. Read the policy's definition of claim and its retention structure against a realistic class action scenario. And treat governance documentation as a coverage asset, because underwriters price it and plaintiffs test it. Organizations that do these three things tend to find the exercise inexpensive. Organizations that do not tend to find out why it mattered.

Discuss this with a risk advisor

A brief conversation is usually enough to establish whether this exposure applies to your organization.

Book a Strategy Call